Manhattan Pizzeria

Enjoy authentic New York-style pizza at Manhattan Pizzeria in Indianapolis! Savor delicious slices, garlic knots, calzones, wings, breadsticks, and marinara sauce. Visit us at 6225 W 56th St or call +1 317-552-2141.

Welcome to Manhattan Pizzeria

Taste the Difference.

Manhattan Pizzeria
Manhattan Pizzeria
Manhattan Pizzeria
Manhattan Pizzeria

Located at 6225 W 56th St, Indianapolis, Manhattan Pizzeria presents a slice of New York right in the heart of Indiana. Known for its mouthwatering New York-style pizza, this local gem delights pizza lovers with a menu full of comforting favorites. Each pizza features a thin, crispy crust that perfectly supports its generous toppings. The vibrant atmosphere buzzes with conversation and laughter, drawing in families and friends who crave the authentic taste of classic American pizza. Popular choices here include delicious garlic knots, savory calzones, and tantalizing wings, making it an ideal spot for any meal. Whether grabbing a slice on the go or settling in for a full pie, Manhattan Pizzeria invites everyone to savor good food and good company.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

6225 W 56th St, Indianapolis, IN 46254, United States

Phone

+1 317-552-2141

Social Media

About

The Culinary Story

Manhattan Pizzeria
Manhattan Pizzeria
Manhattan Pizzeria
Manhattan Pizzeria

Manhattan Pizzeria embraces the spirit of New York in its culinary offerings and vibrant environment. Located conveniently in Indianapolis, this pizzeria welcomes guests with its comforting aromas and lively ambiance. The interior features a cozy setup that invites patrons to unwind, while the efficient service guarantees that cravings are satisfied promptly. For those who can't design their perfect meal, the staff are knowledgeable and glad to recommend the house specialties. Whether visiting for a quick slice during lunch or hosting a family dinner, the customer experience shines bright, thanks to the well-trained team eager to share their love of pizza.

This establishment prides itself on using fresh quality ingredients, ensuring that every bite brings joy. The toppings are generous, and unique sauces, like their savory marinara, elevate the overall flavor. For pizza aficionados, experimenting with various toppings and combinations can lead to exciting new favorites. Seasonal specials often encourage creativity in the kitchen, appealing to adventurous eaters.

Manhattan Pizzeria thrives on its community, where locals often gather to enjoy a casual meal and share laughs. The family-friendly space accommodates diners of all ages well, making it a wonderful spot for after-school hangouts or weekend get-togethers. Special promotions and deals encourage patrons to try something new, like their popular baked ziti pasta, which has quickly become a fan favorite. The inviting vibe keeps drawing customers back, making it an established favorite in the neighborhood.

Overall, Manhattan Pizzeria is a cozy haven where heroes of flavor and community come together. The blend of traditional pizzeria charm with Indianapolis warmth creates an enjoyable escape for anyone craving a taste of New York. No matter the time of day, it's always a good time for pizza.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday10:30 AM-8 PM
  • Monday10:30 AM-8 PM
  • Tuesday10:30 AM-8 PM
  • Wednesday10:30 AM-8 PM
  • Thursday10:30 AM-8 PM
  • Friday10:30 AM-9 PM
  • Saturday10:30 AM-9 PM

Manhattan Pizzeria stands out with its diverse menu loaded with savory options. Signature New York-style pizzas take the spotlight, featuring combinations like pepperoni, sausage, and margarita that elevate the dining experience. Pizza by the slice is perfect for those needing a quick bite, while whole pies cater to families and gatherings. Garlic knots, fresh from the oven, add a satisfying twist for an appetizer or side. Their wings, available in both small and large portions, bring heat and flavor that never disappoints.

The casual atmosphere encourages diners to experience the everyday hustle of New York without leaving their neighborhood. Open daily, Manhattan Pizzeria adapts to the needs of students, families, and late-night cravings alike.

Manhattan Pizzeria

The exterior of Manhattan Pizzeria draws attention, showcasing classic red brick that evokes a sense of history and charm. Bright signage invites hungry diners, creating a welcoming entrance. Outdoor seating options enhance the experience, especially during warmer months. Guests can enjoy their meals in the fresh air, embracing the vibrant life of the surrounding neighborhood. The casual, laid-back vibe complements the delicious food, making it the perfect place to unwind after a hectic day.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

Absolutely blown away! The staff were incredibly friendly and welcoming. Such an inviting atmosphere. The place was clean and spacious, making it a comfortable spot to enjoy a meal. What amazed me the most was the speed at which the food was prepared. We waited for a whole pizza pie less than 10 minutes. Staff speaks Spanish, adding an extra layer of inclusivity to the experience. My family and I will be back for more of their delicious pizza!

M
Mel R.

AMAZING PIZZA AND BREAD STICKS!!!! Great food all around. Definitely a must stop for a good slice of pizza.

D
David L.

This pizzeria is the epitome of NY Style Pizza. A crispy outer crust, and soft and chewy on the inside. This tasty crust held up very well to the toppings. Each pizza had the right amount of sauce, cheese, and toppings. The tomato dipping sauce was garlicky, and one can easily, at least I can, get addicted to it. We enjoyed the cheese, pepperoni, Buffalo chicken, Margherita, and white and Meat Lover rollover pizzas slices. Each was delicious, flavorful, and could easily be folded in half (as they do in NY). We also ordered and enjoyed the Pepperoni Roll and Garlic Breadsticks. I also had a nice conversation with the owner and found out he is from Long Island. He's perfected the craft of creating the perfect NY Style Thin Crust Pizza, and it shows. The inside looks exactly like the pizzeria I am used to visiting in NJ and NY. Manhattan Pizzeria is the best NY Style Pizzeria in Indianapolis. An authentic and tasty version of NY style pizza and garlic knots. A crust that is thin enough crust to stand up to the toppings, and enough of a chew that it isn't a cracker texture. The garlic knots had a golden brown color and a good amount of garlic. It came with a cheesy nacho cheese and a garlicky tomato sauce. Tonight I decided to order the cheese calzone. I've never had one at Manhattan Pizzeria, and I'm not sure why. I was pleasantly surprised to see that it was fried not baked. It created a crispy exterior and a soft interior. It was chock full of Ricotta and Mozzarella cheese. The ricotta could have been seasoned more.

L
Leonard C.

On the same really particular about pizza, I like flavor, but I like thin crust style and good toppings. I tried this pizza place because it was nearby where I live and my family and I have been completely addicted to it. We order almost every week, They are priced reasonably, and their pizza and wings are very good.

J
Jaclyn D.

Being from New Jersey I've been longing for authentic, or close to authentic New Jersey, New York Pizza. Manhattan Pizzeria has fulfilled my void. Very down-to-earth atmosphere and never crowded. You're greeted with politeness soon as you walk in. Slices start at $3, and pies start at $13 with toppings being .75 cents. WELL WORTH IT and you will NOT be disappointed!

K
Keith H.

My dad & I always come to Manhattan when we are in the area and they have never disappointed! Authentic NY Style Pizza slices that are large, not super greasy and full of flavor! They also have a large menu that offers Pizza, Pasta, Sides, Subs, Wings, Desserts & Soda/Water! For a whole Pie/Pizza it cost around $19 or so dollars and for a slice it ranges anywhere between $3-4! If you are ever in the area, come check it out! #AccordingToArmon

A
Armon M.